V-Groove or Knurled? How to Pick the Right MIG Drive Roll

|Gregg Hinton
V-Groove or Knurled? How to Pick the Right MIG Drive Roll

Your wire feeder only does one job: push wire down the torch at a steady speed. The drive rolls are the part that does the pushing. Get the rolls wrong and nothing downstream works properly. The wire slips, flattens, shaves or birdnests, and the liner and contact tip wear out early trying to deal with it.

Picking the right drive roll comes down to three questions: what kind of wire, what size, and what kind of drive.

1. Match the groove to the wire type

The groove pressed into the roll is what grips the wire. Different wires need different grips.

V-groove: solid steel and stainless wire. Solid wire is hard and stiff, so a smooth V-groove grips it cleanly without marking it. This is the standard roll on most feeders running ER70S-6 and similar solid wire.

V-knurled: flux-cored wire. Flux-cored wire is a tube of thin steel wrapped around flux. It's softer than solid wire and it crushes if you squeeze it too hard. The knurled teeth in the groove bite into the surface, so the roll gets traction at lower pressure, without flattening the tube or squeezing the flux out.

U-groove: aluminum. Aluminum is soft enough that a V-groove or knurled roll will deform or shave it. A rounded U-groove supports the wire around more of its surface and pushes without crushing.

The quick rule: smooth V for solid, knurled for flux-core, U for aluminum. When in doubt, follow the wire maker's or the feeder maker's recommendation for that wire.

2. Match the groove size to the wire size

Every groove is cut for a specific wire diameter. A .035" roll is for .035" wire, and a .045" roll is for .045" wire. They aren't interchangeable.

  • Groove too big: the roll can't grip, the wire slips, and you get an erratic feed. The usual reaction is to crank the tension up, which causes the next problem.
  • Groove too small: the wire gets pinched and deformed before it ever reaches the liner.

Many rolls are dual-sided, with a different size groove on each side. If you change wire size, check whether you just need to flip the roll before you order new ones. And always check which groove is facing the wire after you put a roll back on.

3. Match the roll to your drive: 2-roll or 4-roll

Feeders come in two layouts:

  • 2-roll drives have one drive roll and one pressure roll. They're common on all-in-one MIG welders and lighter-duty feeders.
  • 4-roll drives use two pairs of rolls, so they grip the wire in two places. That spreads the load and gives better traction at lower pressure, which is why they're common on industrial feeders and long cable runs.

Rolls, roll kits and wire guides are made for one layout or the other, and they don't interchange between them. A 4-roll kit won't fit a 2-roll drive. The quickest check is to count the rolls on your feeder, then pick parts made for that layout.

And if you are shopping for a new MIG welder, look for an active 4-drive roll system. They provide much better feeding than 2-roll.

Don't forget the wire guides

The rolls aren't the only part in the drive that has to match the wire. The inlet guide (where the wire enters the drive) and the intermediate or inner guides (between the roll pairs) keep the wire lined up with the grooves. If a guide is too big for the wire, the wire wanders off the groove centre. If it's worn, it shaves the wire. Change the guides to match whenever you change wire size, and replace them when the bore is visibly worn.

Tension: less than you think

This is where most feed problems actually start. Drive roll tension that's too tight squeezes round wire into an oval. Oval wire drags through the liner and the contact tip all the way to the arc, wearing both out early and causing burnbacks. With flux-cored wire, too much tension crushes the tube and the flux falls out.

The right setting is the lowest tension that feeds the wire without slipping:

  1. Back the tension right off.
  2. Feed the wire and increase the tension a little at a time until the wire feeds steadily without slipping.
  3. Stop just past that point.

If the rolls are leaving visible flats or bite marks on the wire, it's too tight. Back it off. If you're turning the tension up again and again to stop slipping, the problem probably isn't tension. Check the roll size, the groove type, the liner and the contact tip instead. Most welders give you a guide on the machine close to the tension knob.

Signs your drive rolls are worn

Drive rolls wear slowly, so it's easy to miss. Look for:

  • A groove that's polished, widened or flattened instead of a clean, sharp V
  • Knurled teeth that have worn smooth
  • Wire slipping at a tension setting that used to work
  • Metal dust or fine shavings building up around the drive

Worn rolls slip, and slipping rolls get cranked tighter. That flattens the wire and passes the damage down the line to the liner and the tip. Replacing a worn set of rolls is cheap insurance for everything after it.

Finding the right replacement

Every drive roll, roll kit and wire guide we carry is listed under the part number already on yours. Miller® parts use Miller's six-digit numbers, like 053700 or 079606. Lincoln® inner wire guides use Lincoln's numbers, like KP2173-1. Each product title states the groove type, the wire size and the drive layout, and each product lists the exact feeders and machines it fits. Use the Fits filter on the collection to narrow it to yours.

Shop drive rolls and wire guides →

Running into feed problems further down the torch? Our guide How to Choose a MIG Liner covers the next part in line.

All drive rolls and wire guides are ABICOR Binzel® manufactured and ship anywhere in Canada.


TorchandTip.com is not affiliated with Illinois Tool Works Inc. or The Lincoln Electric Company. Miller® is a trademark of Illinois Tool Works Inc. or its subsidiaries. Lincoln® is a registered trademark of The Lincoln Electric Company. These names are used only to identify the equipment our replacement parts are designed to fit.

0 comments

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.